The blog for SUNY Binghamton's Spring'09 COLI 214B 02 Literature and Society Class. Chapter summaries, analyses and discussion of prescribed texts written by students.
Monday, February 9, 2009
Michael Lampasona
Johnny Truant continues to go mad and his life appears to be falling apart, and the Navidson Record appears to be responsible (at least in his head). More references were made to the Minotaur, and how that can be symbolized by the house. These chapters were interesting, however I did not like the portions of missing text, due to "burn marks" or "ink blotches."
So, here are my discussion questions...
1. How real are Johnny's problems, and does he have an underlying psychological problem?
2. Is there a reason for the house's behavior (why has it gotten more severe)?
3. What are the purpose of the missing information with brackets?
Julie Morvitz
I thought it was very interesting how the reader went from thinking that one brother was going to die (Navidson) to thinking the other was going to die (Tom). I wasn’t sure Navidson would die even when Tom had left him in the hallway, though. I still wasn’t sure he was completely gone even after he had been gone for a few days. When he emerged, I thought the danger was gone because no one would attempt the dangerous hallway again. My thoughts were disproven when Tom was suddenly eaten by the house while trying to escape. When Navidson’s family tried to leave the house, it basically tried to engulf them. I liked how the house took pieces of the people who tried to explore it by taking bits of their clothing, and then when they tried to escape, it literally tried to swallow them up.
I also liked the different opinions on the movie. Some of them made no sense, and others assumed that Karen was just lonely so she made up this story, which apparently symbolized loneliness. I also thought it was very funny that Hunter S. Thompson thought Karen had taken drugs before she made this film, because that’s how the story seems to an outsider.
Discussion Questions
1. Why didn’t Karen tell her viewers that the film was real?
2. Does Navidson plan on joining his family in New York?
3. Why does Delial affect Navidson so much?
4. Do you think the house is a portal into another dimension?
Katherine Tesi
Wax, Reston, Tom and an already deceased Jed, return from the hallway without Navidson. After a few more days, Navidson returns one evening, limping. Holloway’s tapes are revealed and we are told that he committed suicide while in the house. Karen is more ready than ever to leave Virginia and go back to New York with the kids. One night as they are all packing, the house begins to collapse. All the walls begin to blacken, windows disappear and the house seems to be becoming like the hallway. Navidson returns to the collapsing house to save Karen and Tom sacrifices himself to save Daisy. Karen returns to New York and Navidson promises to meet her soon, where she makes a short film of the Navidson Record. She shows her film to many others for criticisms and opinions. It is also revealed to the reader that Delial could be the name of a Sudanese child once photographed by Navidson. Possibly the most interesting detail revealed however, is the fact that the wall samples taken from within the labyrinth prove to be ranging in age from a few years old to millions of years old; some older than the earth itself.
1. Has Karen too become more obsessed with the house?
2. Why do the children seem so uninterested in the happenings of the house?
3. Why does the house have such a different relationship with adults, children and animals?
Kristy Medina
Probably one of my favorite quotes in the book so far, "I call architecture frozen music." The house is a work of art. So if it is like a work of art then it reflects the author's mood and perspective. One of the climaxes of the novel so far was when Holloway shots Wax by accident thinking it was the monster and instead of helping him he runs away because he doesn't want to end up in jail. Also, Johnnie talks about the exploration of Magellan and compares it to Holloway. This point of this is to show how Magellan died but proves his leadership which I feel like might foreshadow something that might happen to Navidson. By chapter ten, a more prominent theme of psychology is actually revealed. Each character in the novel creates their own perception of what the house's darkness really is. The theme of a changing nature of the house. Tom's Story in chapter eleven reveals Tom's fears of the monster but shows it in a more satirical light. Tom and Will, although twins, are completely different which is very common psychologically. Toms is more passive and Will is more aggressive. Tom is completly alone and keeps the radio contact. He is really sarcastic and likes making jokes. He tries to make fun of the monster to calm his nerves down. The echos reappear and Karen gets scared at what Will is doing. Tom never reached the bottom of the staircase so Reston plans to throw a rope down the staircase. However, the rope starts to vanish and Navidson starts slipping; the stairs also start expanding.
Finally, a point is made about the leaves and how it looks in the sky. It all shows a relation to the changing nature of the house, the characters, and how leaves constantly change.
Questions:
-How do you go about reading the boxes?
- Why are the stanzas ripped, like the "rzzzzz..." between each paragraph?
-What does improving energy mean when related to dragons, crystals, goldfish, and bullfrogs?
-Wy did they buy a house without plumbing, lights, and heating?
Why does it in end in white? Does it mean death?
Alyson Bernero
Why doesn't Lude get help for Johnny?
When will Karen realize she can't stand by Navidson's actions anymore?
Will Johnny realize that he's going to drive himself mad before its too late?
Will Navidson survive his adventures?
Natalya Gornopolskaya
Questions:
1. Why does Johnny want to find the house?
2. Did Navidson take death into consideration before re-entering the house?
3. Has Karen gone mad with her love for Navidson?
4. Will Johnny and Thumper ever be together?
5. Is Johnny seriously leaving his life behind, never to return?
Emily Skahill
Tung Kim
What is the story of Echo and Zeus? Did something like that happen in the house?
After Johnny reads the brown papers he starts to feel really sick and then feel better again, do you think that the house is doing all this?
Hillary is the Navidson's dog and Mallory is their cat ran into the house down the hall way and this right into the backyard? Can this happen?
As Holloway and Navidson's investigate the hallway their minds start to fill up with a sense finding something strange will they find it?
Holloway starts to flirt with Navidson’s wife and he doesn’t like it, does it seem like something is going to happen like the Echo story?
Tung Kim
What is with the word House printed in blue?
As the family moves into their new house and start to explore do you think that the children sense that something strange is happening?
Is the house really hunted?
Does Navidson seem as if he is little off and weird? I mean he does kind of disregard the fact that something straggle just happened but instead of just running away from it he stays and wonders how it got there.
Does the address Ash Tree Lane of the house have any meaning to the story?
Robert Stevens
The house is also flexing its muscles, as it now has the ability to shape-shift beyond the confines of the Laybrinth. This is the final straw for all concerned, and they finally leave the house. The remainder of the story focuses on the aftermath and recollections. Several celebreties give their take on the film. Karen's infidelities are also explored in more detail, as well as her new found emotional independence from Will. Will himself has also become more distant and isolated, unwilling to associate with Karen and most other people. We also finally find out who Delial is.
Johnny Truant is further slipping into madness as well. He has sealed off his apartment from the outside world, most of his utilites have been shut off, and he is facing eviction. He is so consumed at this point that even Thumper dosen't have an effect on him. What happened to him is exactly what happend to Zampano (although I'm not sure if Zampano kept a .45 a .357 and a Weatherbee 300 mag rifle around to maintain "some kind of fucking control")
Sunday, February 8, 2009
Kristin Todd
Natalya Gornopolskaya
Questions:
1. Is Johnny’s behavior rationally cautious?
2. Will we ever hear an explanation for why the house collapsed or how it came to exist?
3. Why did Navidson leave Karen?
4. Have the children been psychologically traumatized?
5. Will Johnny ever return to normal, will anyone ever help him?
Victoria Gornopolskaya
Questions:
What is the significance of Johnny's mother's locket? What did the letter say?
Did the house cause Navidson psychological damage?
Will Johnny Truant ever get his normal life back?
Carly Cooper
One question I have is about all these people who responded to Karen’s short film, they seem to all be hitting on her, even the women, I was wondering what the significance of that was?
Another question is about Navidson, where is he? What is he doing or trying to discover? Why doesn’t he return to his family? My last question is regarding Johnny, what is wrong with him? His story has become much less interesting as his psychological states get more sever. What is wrong with him? How has this story changed him so drastically?
Saturday, February 7, 2009
John Bonhomme Jr.
Questions
Is Karen intentionally getting fame off the house footage?
Why the heck would Will go back to the house and leave his family?
Does Karen still love Will?
Friday, February 6, 2009
Alyson Bernero
Another topic discussed in class was that the role of the artist or creator of a work has changed somewhat dramatically over time. Years ago the person who created the work was intimately associated with their work and was recongnized for it. Now however, the artist is no longer as important as the work itself. There has become a divide between the creator and the creation. Perhaps this is why a good author loses himself entirely within in his work.
We also discussed the suspension of disbelief and its relevence to both the short story and House of Leaves. The suspension of disbelief is something is something readers do when they overlook their disbelief in order to fully encase themselves within the reading. This is especially necessary when reading books that are science fiction, or extremely unrealistic. House of Leaves requires its readers to put aside their doubts or their reluctance and give into such a complicated and seemlingly unrealistic story. I think it is very necessary to do this while reading especially in order to not only enjoy the book, but also to get the best understanding of it.
Thursday, February 5, 2009
Elisabeth Jeremko
DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
1) Why does Danielewski wait only till now to really transform the text, taking more liberties with its actual organization?
2) Tom comes up and again and even has a short analysis of his story written…does Tom serve a purpose…perhaps as a contrast against Will, his brother?
3) Is there any significance to the name "The Atrocity" described by Johnny Truant?
4) When Tom says, "I'm coming in" what does he mean exactly? Has he been sucked into the psychological mind games of the labyrinth as well?
Nian Liu
Chapter IX-XII
In these chapters, Holloway and his team finally reaches the bottom of the spiral staircase and finds themselves not relieved by achieving their main "goal" but rather even more stressed, finding even more corridors and small rooms. The team goes into desperation and the continuous growl continue to separate Holloway from Jed and Wax. As Holloway goes off to chase the untraceable growl, Jed and Wax continue to climb the spiral staircase. As they continue up, Holloway accidentally shoots Wax in the arm and this time Holloway goes crazy and leaves the two. Jed frustrated, scared, and hopeless carries Wax and Holloway who lost all sense of reality shoots at the two men which made them go into hiding. The house seems to be devouring not only their hopes and sense of time space and morality but their shoelaces, neon markings, and backup supplies. Jed sobbing and venting, he talks to the recorder and pounds on the floor, and due to this action it "echoed" to Navidson' s living room. The pounding sounded like a SOS and it hyped up Navidson Tom and Reston, so they went into the hallway after eight days of Holloway not coming back. The chapter goes on about exploring the maze in the house and as for Johnny Traunt, we learn a little more about his sexual encounters with various women. Johnny's life soon becomes a life lived in fear, where he is constantly hiding from something which he thinks is coming for him.
Questions:
1) How come it only took Reston and Will 20 minutes to get down the stairs while for Holloway it took hours and hours?
2) Do you think the drugs and Zampano's reading has effected Traunt's way in experiencing situations in his life?
3) Whats with the blank lines on the bottom of 118?
Natalya Gornopolskaya
Questions:
1. Was the abandoned Pekinese meant as a symbol for Johnny; does its violent end foreshadow something?
2. What happened to Jed as Navidson and Reston found him, is he alright?
3. Why does the hallway allow for each man to get hoisted up to safety, except for Navidson?
4. How can Karen keep her sanity while her husband is off “exploring” again?
5. What will become of Johnny now that he has lost his job?
Kristin Todd
These chapters were about exploring the labyrinth. I thought that the adventure of finding what was going on inside the house was very interesting. Reading what these people were going through to find out what they're living with is captivating. It frightened me seeing the effects the labyrinth has on the men, especially Tom. I am interested in seeing what happens inside the house, based on the strange things that have already happened. Especially with the fung shui animal figurines disappearing.
Discussion Questions:
1. How was it that Tom was able to pull up the people from the house and not from the to of the stairs?
2. What is the figure that they saw?